Rendered at 23:32:28 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time) with Cloudflare Workers.
shomp 1 days ago [-]
The fact that the perceptron is modeled after the neuron should make this an unsurprising find, but the question of active sentience starting as early as in vitro should give everyone pause for where personhood begins. That zinc spark.
serf 1 days ago [-]
>That zinc spark.
it's not a literal spark. it was a florescence caused by an expulsion of zinc ions during egg cortical reaction in the midst of FluoZin-3, a dye that binds to zinc and fluoresces.
I think that experiment does a bad job at explaining that, because every damn person in the world is using that as some kind of 'spark of life' analogy when really there is no easier way to prevent triploidy than to force everything away for a moment.
shomp 1 days ago [-]
Describing the chemistry doesn't invalidate the metaphor. It's still the moment fertilization initiates embryonic development. Explaining the gears of a watch doesn't make "the moment it starts keeping time" any less real, nor does it explain time.
Kim_Bruning 1 days ago [-]
You have to squint really hard.
I was doing some modelling over Christmas, and was digging in to the papers. It turns out that bioneurons are not very much like perceptrons at all. Depending on type, they are more like a small microcontroller of some sort.
stubish 23 hours ago [-]
Sentience as defined in the paper is a really low bar. Personhood probably requires consciousness, if we could define and test for that.
vercaemert 1 days ago [-]
at present, it's just a fun discussion
the complexity of advanced connectomes is so far beyond our imaging capabilities that we have no way of knowing how far away from understanding intelligence we are
stubish 23 hours ago [-]
Good on them for defining what they mean by 'sentience'. I think it is the definition where my thermostat exhibits sentience.
it's not a literal spark. it was a florescence caused by an expulsion of zinc ions during egg cortical reaction in the midst of FluoZin-3, a dye that binds to zinc and fluoresces.
I think that experiment does a bad job at explaining that, because every damn person in the world is using that as some kind of 'spark of life' analogy when really there is no easier way to prevent triploidy than to force everything away for a moment.
I was doing some modelling over Christmas, and was digging in to the papers. It turns out that bioneurons are not very much like perceptrons at all. Depending on type, they are more like a small microcontroller of some sort.
the complexity of advanced connectomes is so far beyond our imaging capabilities that we have no way of knowing how far away from understanding intelligence we are
( "Brain" In A Dish Acts As Autopilot Living Computer, 2005 )